32 cases: 4 open, 14 closed (disposition not in docket feed), 12 dismissed, 2 judgment
Cottingham v. Automation Personnel Services Inc open
District Court, N.D. Alabama · No. 2:26-cv-00507 · Filed Mar 26, 2026
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Open — no termination date on the docket (bulk snapshot 2026-09-30) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in AL (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. Environment Litigation Group PC open
District Court, N.D. Alabama · No. 2:25-cv-01684 · Filed Oct 2, 2025
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Open — no termination date on the docket (bulk snapshot 2026-09-30) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in AL (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. Automation Personnel Services Inc open
District Court, N.D. Alabama · No. 2:25-cv-00761 · Filed May 15, 2025
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Open — no termination date on the docket (bulk snapshot 2026-09-30) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in AL (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. Marmaxx Operating Corp. closed
District Court, E.D. Texas · No. 5:23-cv-00020 · Filed Mar 1, 2023 · Closed Jun 6, 2023
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2023-06-06 (disposition not included in the bulk docket feed — see docket) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in TX (not a filing state)
S&R Egg Farms Inc v. Cottingham & Butler Insurance Services Inc closed
District Court, E.D. Wisconsin · No. 2:23-cv-00222 · Filed Feb 16, 2023 · Closed Apr 14, 2023
Role of Cottingham & Butler Insurance Services Inc:
Defendant · Outcome:
Terminated 2023-04-14 (disposition not included in the bulk docket feed — see docket) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in WI (not a filing state)
COTTINGHAM v. LUITPOLD PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. closed
District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · No. 2:22-cv-02561 · Filed Jun 30, 2022 · Closed Jan 2, 2024
Role of COTTINGHAM:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2024-01-02 (disposition not included in the bulk docket feed — see docket) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in PA (not a filing state)
COTTINGHAM v. Wal-Mart Stores East, L.P. closed
District Court, S.D. Florida · No. 0:20-cv-61991 · Filed Sep 30, 2020 · Closed Feb 22, 2022 ·
Nature of suit:
P.I.: Other
· Cause:
28:1332 Diversity-Notice of Removal
Role of COTTINGHAM:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2022-02-22 (disposition not included in the bulk docket feed — see docket) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in FL (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. The Ultimate Software Group, Inc. closed
District Court, C.D. Illinois · No. 1:20-cv-01172 · Filed Apr 24, 2020 · Closed Oct 19, 2021 ·
Nature of suit:
190 Contract: Other
· Cause:
28:1441 Notice of Removal--Other Contract
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2021-10-19 (disposition not included in the bulk docket feed — see docket) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in IL (not a filing state)
Yasenyev v. Cottingham & Butler Claim Services, Inc. dismissed
District Court, S.D. Texas · No. 4:19-cv-03607 · Filed Sep 24, 2019 · Closed Oct 23, 2020 ·
Nature of suit:
P.I.: Other
· Cause:
28:1332 Diversity-Notice of Removal
Role of Cottingham & Butler Claim Services, Inc.:
Defendant · Outcome:
Terminated 2020-10-23 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Dismissed: settled Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in TX (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. ReliaStar Life Insurance Company dismissed
District Court, W.D. Tennessee · No. 2:19-cv-02550 · Filed Aug 19, 2019 · Closed Jan 2, 2020 ·
Nature of suit:
791 Employee Retirement Income Security Act
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2020-01-02 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Dismissed: settled Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in TN (not a filing state)
Freeport Title & Guaranty Inc Land Trust v. Cottingham closed
District Court, N.D. Georgia · No. 1:19-cv-03465 · Filed Jul 31, 2019 · Closed Nov 6, 2019 ·
Nature of suit:
230 Rent, lease, ejectment
Role of Cottingham:
Defendant · Outcome:
Terminated 2019-11-06 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Remanded to state court Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in GA (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. Davol, Inc. open
District Court, S.D. Ohio · No. 2:19-cv-02394 · Filed Jun 7, 2019 ·
Nature of suit:
367 Health care / pharm
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Open — no termination date on the docket (bulk snapshot 2026-09-30) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in OH (not a filing state)
Park Hotels & Resorts Inc. v. Cottingham closed
District Court, N.D. Georgia · No. 1:19-cv-01629 · Filed Apr 10, 2019 · Closed Oct 17, 2019 ·
Nature of suit:
190 Other contract actions
· Cause:
28:1332 Diversity-Breach of Contract
Role of Cottingham:
Defendant · Outcome:
Terminated 2019-10-17 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Statistical closing Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in GA (not a filing state)
Ausborne v. Cottingham & Butler Claims Services Inc. dismissed
District Court, S.D. West Virginia · No. 1:19-cv-00116 · Filed Feb 14, 2019 · Closed Jul 2, 2019 ·
Nature of suit:
370 Other Fraud
· Cause:
28:1332 Diversity-Fraud
Role of Cottingham & Butler Claims Services Inc.:
Defendant · Outcome:
Terminated 2019-07-02 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Dismissed: settled Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in WV (not a filing state)
Aurora Cooperative Elevator Company v. Cottingham judgment
District Court, N.D. Texas · No. 5:19-cv-00016 · Filed Jan 31, 2019 · Closed Sep 14, 2020 ·
Nature of suit:
370 Other fraud
Role of Cottingham:
Defendant · Outcome:
Terminated 2020-09-14 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Judgment on consent; judgment for unknown Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in TX (not a filing state)
Cottingham & Butler Claim Services, Inc v. Conduent Care Solutions, LLC closed
District Court, N.D. Iowa · No. 2:17-cv-01033 · Filed Dec 19, 2017 · Closed Apr 12, 2018 ·
Nature of suit:
190 Contract: Other
· Cause:
28:1441 Petition For Removal--Other Contract
Role of Cottingham & Butler Claim Services, Inc:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2018-04-12 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Remanded to state court Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in IA (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. Citigroup, Inc. dismissed
District Court, E.D. Kentucky · No. 5:17-cv-00452 · Filed Nov 17, 2017 · Closed Jun 1, 2018 ·
Nature of suit:
890 Other Statutory Actions
· Cause:
28:1331 Fed. Question
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2018-06-01 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Voluntarily dismissed Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in the person's filing state (KY)
Cottingham v. Midland Credit Management dismissed
District Court, N.D. Illinois · No. 1:17-cv-00238 · Filed Jan 12, 2017 · Closed Feb 8, 2017 ·
Nature of suit:
890 Other Statutory Actions
· Cause:
28:1331 Federal Question
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2017-02-08 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Dismissed: settled Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in IL (not a filing state)
COTTINGHAM v. BAYER HEALTHCARE PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. closed
District Court, D. New Jersey · No. 2:16-cv-08838 · Filed Nov 29, 2016 · Closed Apr 7, 2017 ·
Nature of suit:
367 Health care / pharm
Role of COTTINGHAM:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2017-04-07 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Multi-district litigation transfer Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in NJ (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. Janssen Research & Development LLC dismissed
District Court, E.D. Louisiana · No. 2:16-cv-15445 · Filed Oct 12, 2016 · Closed May 21, 2020 ·
Nature of suit:
367 Health care / pharm
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2020-05-21 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Dismissed: settled Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in LA (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. Janssen Research & Development, LLC dismissed
District Court, E.D. Louisiana · No. 2:16-cv-13972 · Filed Aug 19, 2016 · Closed May 12, 2020 ·
Nature of suit:
367 Health care / pharm
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2020-05-12 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Dismissed: settled Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in LA (not a filing state)
Cottingham & Butler Insurance Services, Inc. v. Patel closed
District Court, N.D. Iowa · No. 2:15-cv-01036 · Filed Dec 2, 2015 · Closed Mar 18, 2016 ·
Nature of suit:
Contract: Other
· Cause:
28:1441 Petition for Removal- Breach of Contract
Role of Cottingham & Butler Insurance Services, Inc.:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2016-03-18 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Remanded to state court Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in IA (not a filing state)
COTTINGHAM v. MED SHIELD, INC. dismissed
District Court, S.D. Indiana · No. 1:13-cv-01021 · Filed Jun 25, 2013 · Closed Aug 6, 2013 ·
Nature of suit:
890 Other statutory actions
Role of COTTINGHAM:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2013-08-06 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Dismissed: want of prosecution Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in IN (not a filing state)
Pinebridge Investments LLC v. Cottingham dismissed
District Court, S.D. New York · No. 1:12-cv-06217 · Filed Aug 14, 2012 · Closed Sep 7, 2012 ·
Nature of suit:
190 Other contract actions
Role of Cottingham:
Defendant · Outcome:
Terminated 2012-09-07 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Voluntarily dismissed Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in NY (not a filing state)
Suretec Insurance Company v. Cottingham closed
District Court, S.D. California · No. 3:09-cv-02132 · Filed Sep 29, 2009 · Closed Mar 16, 2010 ·
Nature of suit:
190 Other contract actions
Role of Cottingham:
Defendant · Outcome:
Terminated 2010-03-16 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Transfer to another district Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in CA (not a filing state)
Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. Cottingham dismissed
District Court, S.D. Ohio · No. 1:07-cv-00735 · Filed Sep 6, 2007 · Closed Jan 8, 2008 ·
Nature of suit:
220 Foreclosure
Role of Cottingham:
Defendant · Outcome:
Terminated 2008-01-08 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Voluntarily dismissed Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in OH (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. Policy Studies, Inc. judgment
District Court, M.D. Tennessee · No. 3:07-cv-00580 · Filed May 24, 2007 · Closed Mar 21, 2008 ·
Nature of suit:
Personal Property: Other
· Cause:
28:1332 Diversity-Property Damage
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2008-03-21 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Judgment on motion before trial; judgment for defendant Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in TN (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. National Rural dismissed
District Court, D. South Carolina · No. 4:02-cv-00677 · Filed Mar 1, 2002 · Closed Aug 27, 2003 ·
Nature of suit:
791 Employee Retirement Income Security Act
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 2003-08-27 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Dismissed: settled Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in SC (not a filing state)
Allstate Insurance v. Cottingham closed
District Court, E.D. Texas · No. 6:92-cv-00322 · Filed Jun 2, 1992 · Closed Jun 22, 1992
Role of Cottingham:
Defendant · Outcome:
Terminated 1992-06-22 (disposition not included in the bulk docket feed — see docket) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in TX (not a filing state)
Cottingham v. Anchor Packing Co closed
District Court, C.D. Illinois · No. 1:90-cv-01124 · Filed Apr 19, 1990 · Closed Jul 29, 1991
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 1991-07-29 (disposition not included in the bulk docket feed — see docket) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in IL (not a filing state)
COTTINGHAM v. SEABOARD SYSTEMS ETAL dismissed
District Court, W.D. Kentucky · No. · Filed Mar 14, 1985 · Closed Jun 7, 1989 ·
Nature of suit:
330 Federal employers' liability
Role of COTTINGHAM:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 1989-06-07 — FJC Integrated Database disposition: Dismissed: other Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in the person's filing state (KY)
Cottingham v. Mid Continent Theater Company closed
District Court, D. North Dakota · No. 1:85-cv-00054 · Filed Feb 27, 1985 · Closed Oct 24, 1986
Role of Cottingham:
Plaintiff · Outcome:
Terminated 1986-10-24 (disposition not included in the bulk docket feed — see docket) Docket on CourtListener ↗same rare surname (4 people in Form D filings, 104 federal dockets); surname only in the caption; court in ND (not a filing state)
What was searched
Sources searched: CourtListener bulk data (RECAP dockets as of 2026-09-30; recall-first rule 10-24) — federal district + bankruptcy courts State courts: not covered (one-tap state court links under Look further). PACER: not searched. · Last checked Oct 24, 2026, 2:20 AM ET.
Court records show docket facts only; we never restate allegations as facts. Outcome wording comes from the docket feed; where it does not state a disposition we say so.
State courts: not covered (one-tap state court links under Look further). No state offers a lawful automated statewide source PartnerFacts can use today. Texas (re:SearchTX) terms prohibit storing results in a database open to third parties; New York (WebCivil) and Massachusetts (MassCourts) require a browser check that blocks scripted queries; California has no statewide index (58 county portals; Rule of Court 2.503 grants name-based access case by case); Florida, Utah and Illinois offer paid or partial access whose terms for automated use are unverified. Washington (dw.courts.wa.gov; bulk index reports under a JISC data-dissemination agreement), Delaware (CourtConnect; Court of Chancery not included) and Arizona (apps.azcourts.gov/publicaccess, which has an official channel to request high-volume access) are the candidates; PartnerFacts will request written permission before any automated search. Federal courts are searched through CourtListener / RECAP.